The first being the orgin where Horace created it the second being where it was in "The Man Behind The Curtain" which was the only spot Ben was aware of and the third being were Hurley saw it in "The Beginning Of The End" after Hurley saw it vanish it merely moved back to the first spot where Horace built it and where Locke was directed to in Cabin Fever, again Horace was probably the MIB in his guise in Locke's dream Jacob probably had put circles of ash around the places the cabin would move to, hence why Locke found the ash circle but no cabin.
However some time after this MIB learned of this cabin teleporatation and the exact spots it would move to and Jacob probably decided to abandon living there and merely moved out leaving it free for the MIB to occupy.
It was also the MIB in the cabin as Christian Shephard when Hurley saw it, the eye could have been the real ghost of the unknown man as Hurley can see the dead warning Hurley to run from the MIB's presence. The dream Locke had was the MIB in Horace's form instructing Locke how to get there and then was also him inside the cabin when Locke finally arrived. Lostpedia Explore. Explore Wikis Community Central. Register Don't have an account? View source.
History Talk Stated as questions or possibilities avoid question marks, "Maybe", "I think", etc. More appropriate for another article. Illogical or previously disproven. Proven by canon source, and moved to main article. Speculative and lacking any evidence to support arguments. Responding to another theory use discussion page instead. This does not include responses that can stand alone as its own theory. Usage of an indented bullet does not imply the statement is a response.
Categories TheoryTab articles. Universal Conquest Wiki. Main Article. Theories about The Cabin. At this point we know that MiB is Shepard's father on the island his ability to take on the forms of the dead , which would imply that he is the one now using the Cabin. It is not a surprise that MiB has been manipulating people just as much as Jacob in order to win his side of the Game between the two of them.
I believe Ben says this is Jacob because it is later revealed that Ben has never seen Jacob until the night MiB manipulated him into killing Jacob. So he would say this is Jacob because he saw the strange occurrences with Locke on that first visit.
His bewilderment and expectation that no one would actually be there would lead him to believe that it was Jacob when it was not.
But all the episodes involving the Cabin and what we know of MiB points to the extreme possibility of him being the one that Locke and Ben saw inside the Cabin. For me, it's clear that it was indeed MiB.
We see the mysterious man in there when Ben and Locke make their first visit, along with a short shot of "the eye". The next time we see the cabin, we see Christian Shepard in there along with "the eye", this is in S4E1 when Hurley runs into the moving cabin.
Of course, near the end of Season 4 when Locke goes in alone, it's Christian Shepard in there with Claire, who later talked about MiB impersonating her father, making the connection of MiB with the cabin even stronger.
In S5 MiB makes Ben admit that he never met Jacob, and that he was "as confused as Locke" about what happened in the cabin. Finally, Ilana and her team go there and she concludes that Jacob "hasn't been there in a long time", the ash circle which we know keeps the MiB out from S6 has been broken, and "somebody else has been using it". I would say all the clues are there that we only ever saw MiB in the cabin, although apparently Jacob did use it at some point, with the ash circle in tact to keep MiB away.
It's worth noting that the primary thing MiB uses to get Ben to kill Jacob and it's easy to forget this because later the focus is on Alex is Ben's jealousy over his sense that the island, i. Jacob, prefers Locke to him. I think that MiB gave his "help me" message only to Locke as an early step in making Ben jealous of Locke, eventually leading Ben to murder Locke, only to have MiB take Locke's form - making Ben even more jealous thinking the island has even resurrected the "chosen" Locke.
Then, "Locke" demands to see Jacob and is immediately taken there, while Ben was denied, leading Ben to kill Jacob. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top.
Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. He refused. About that same time, Benjamin Linus and his father joined the Dharma Initiative. The implication, it seems, is that Ben has been walking the path that was originally meant for Locke. But Ben is his own person, of course, and he has done things differently from what Locke would have done, and this, in turn, has created further changes in the original order of things — changes that I think a certain ticked-off, Island-deprived billionaire named Charles Widmore is trying to reverse.
Unless I? Now, I have no idea how he intends to do that. And so that wreckage of Oceanic at the bottom of the ocean? Other details may be symbolic or foreshadowing of events to come.
Did the nosebleed mean that Horace was a Dharma time traveler? Was the looping nature of the dream a clue that the castaways are caught in a time loop? And where was Olivia? So who preceded him in leadership? And who ordered the gassing of the Dharma barracks? So maybe Charles Widmore? Time-looped John Locke? The death of the freighter doctor First, let me say that I think Kevin Durand, the actor who plays Keamy, is emerging as a real find this season; he plays that mercenary part with a scene-stealing mix of menace and damaged vulnerability.
To that end, he pulled out a secret Dharma file that revealed to him where Ben will probably go next what was that — the script for the season finale? Finally, where was Jacob? Claire sat nearby flashing an array of coy smiles, implying some kind of enlightenment or some kind of evil.
What do you think? Is she dead? I think so. And where did Jacob go? Home Article 'Lost' recap: Finding the cabin. Save FB Tweet More. Terry O'Quinn, Lost. Close this dialog window Streaming Options.
Episode Recaps Lost. S6 E17 Recap 'Lost' finale recap, part two: Step into the light. S4 E2 Recap ''Lost'' recap: New hostilities. Lost, Henry Ian Cusick. S4 E5 Recap Recap: ''Lost'' in space-time.
Lost, Harold Perrineau.
0コメント